Hello dear
Welcome To Lucy's New York Style Pizza - Idaho Falls
Welcome to Lucy's New York Style Pizza - Idaho Falls, where the spirit of New York pizza comes alive in a cozy setting. Located at 560 W Broadway St, this charming eatery is renowned for its hand-tossed, thin-crust pizzas that boast an incredible array of flavors, from classic cheese and pepperoni to unique, monthly specials. Diners rave about the fresh ingredients, with standout dishes like the Caprese Salad and the meaty 18" pizza. With a friendly atmosphere and attentive service, Lucy's offers not just satisfying food, but a delightful dining experience that elevates the pizza game in Idaho Falls.
About
Lucy's New York Style Pizza - Idaho Falls
Welcome to Lucy's New York Style Pizza, where the heart of New York meets the vibrant spirit of Idaho Falls! Located conveniently at 560 W Broadway St, this pizzeria offers a slice of authentic New York pizza with a local twist. With a passionate dedication to quality, Lucy's ensures that every pizza is crafted to perfection, promising a delightful experience for both locals and visitors alike.
As you stroll in, the ambiance is reminiscent of a classic city eatery, complete with the sounds of 80’s and 90’s rock softly playing in the background. The decor strikes a balance between comfort and nostalgic charm, creating a welcoming atmosphere for pizza lovers. From the moment you step inside, the attentive service is evident, making you feel right at home.
One of the standout features of Lucy's is the gluten-free pizza options. You can build your masterpiece with a GF Build Your Own Pizza, starting at just $12.00, allowing you to tailor your meal with any toppings or sauces you choose. Customers rave about their unique GF Half&Half Specialty pizzas, an award-winning combination for those who can’t decide between favorites. If you're in the mood for a protein-packed delight, the GF Meaty pizza, loaded with pepperoni, ham, sausage, and bacon, is a must-try at $17.00.
The menu goes beyond pizzas too, showcasing mouthwatering subs like the Meatball Sub ($10.00) and the Chicken Parmesan Sub ($9.50), each crafted with house-made marinara sauce and gooey mozzarella cheese. Customers speak highly of the flavors, with one reviewer describing their pizza experience as a "party in your mouth,” elevating your tastebud expectations to new heights.
And let’s not forget the thirsty pizza enthusiast! Lucy's offers a selection of bottled beers at the affordable price of $3.00, making it the perfect accompaniment to a slice or two. The Angry Orchard, Corona, and Twisted Tea are among the favorites that complement the pies beautifully.
Patrons consistently praise Lucy's for their fast service, polite staff, and always tasty food. The enthusiasm is palpable, as customers express that each visit is met with consistency in quality and flavor. If you’re searching for pizza that transcends being just food and instead delivers an experience, Lucy's New York Style Pizza is the place to go. Just be warned—once you’ve tasted these delightful offerings, your standards for pizza may never be the same!
So, if you find yourself wandering the streets of Idaho Falls, make sure to stop by Lucy's and treat yourself to a slice (or two) at this unforgettable haven for pizza lovers!
Book a table
Make A Reservation
“ Our team’s been at this Lucy’s a few times and it has always been great. Today I was early to an appointment nearby but didn’t want much so I popped it and got a single slice. Awesome as always! ”
“ I grew up in NY and i gotta say wow! This pizza is legit! I got an 18 “ half plain half pepperoni and ordered it well done. Incredible crust that was better than a lot of NY pizza back home. If I lived here I’d be here all the time. Great ZA! ”
“ Fast service, polite & knowledgeable servers, tasty food with a unique twist, & interesting decor. The atmosphere was classic city and very comfortable. ”
“ The first bite? It's like a party in your mouth and everyone's invited... especially your tastebuds, they're the VIPs. It's a whole mood. You'll forget your troubles, your bills, maybe even your own name for a few minutes. It's so good, it's almost suspicious. Through the eating experience, you'll probably make involuntary happy noises. You might start inventing new words to describe the flavor. Don't be surprised if you find yourself trying to hug the pizza. It's a natural reaction to something this good. So, if you're tired of pizza that's just food, then get yourself to this place. It's a guaranteed riot for your tastebuds. Just be prepared to have your pizza standards raised so high, every other pizza place will seem like a sad imitation. You've been warned... and you're welcome! Go grab these pies now! ”
“ Great little pizza joint right on Broadway in downtown Idaho Falls. 80’s and 90’ rock playing quietly in the background. Pizza was excellent, just what we were looking for. Our server Nat was very attentive, friendly and seemed genuinely intent on making our experience as good as it could possibly be. Thanks Nat!! ”
“ Best pizza place ever five star rating. It is so good. The pizza is awesome. The cheese sticks, the pepperoni pizza and the cheese pizza is really good. Try it’s the best one in the town. Review came from my 7 year old:) ”
“ I ate here with an upstate New Yorker and her an I loved it! I got the pepperoni and loved it. It’s a pizza place but the wings are amazing too. They’re really crispy but not dry! Very nice service too. ”
“ Today, my family, a few friends, and their dog enjoyed lunch at Lucy’s after spending the morning at the farmers market. We sat outside on a beautiful day and were lucky to be served by Ryan. He was fantastic—friendly, attentive, and very knowledgeable about the menu. He got our order exactly right, and the food came out in a timely manner. Ryan went above and beyond by keeping our drinks full and even bringing out a bowl of water for the dog without us asking. That small gesture really stood out. The food was absolutely incredible—some of the best pizza I’ve ever had. The BBQ chicken calzone was my personal favorite. Between the top-notch service and amazing food, we will definitely be back. Great food and great service can be hard to come by, but we found both today at Lucy’s. Thanks again, Ryan! ”